Worn below the minimum
Every rotor has a minimum thickness stamped on it. Once it's worn past that number, it has to be replaced, however smooth it looks.
Home » Brake answers »
Brake answers
The short answer
You need new rotors as well as pads when the rotors are worn below the minimum thickness stamped on them, deeply grooved, cracked, or uneven enough to make the brakes shake. If the rotors are smooth, flat and thick enough, new pads alone may be all you need. The only way to know is to measure them, and that's part of the free brake inspection at Budget Brakes.
From the Budget Brakes shops · Updated

Every rotor has a minimum thickness stamped on it. Once it's worn past that number, it has to be replaced, however smooth it looks.
Pads worn to the metal cut grooves into the rotor. Light marks are normal. Grooves you can catch a fingernail in usually mean a new rotor. Grinding when you brake.
A steering wheel or pedal that shakes when you brake usually means the rotors have worn unevenly. Why the wheel shakes.
Cracks, or blue and dark spots on the rotor face, mean it has overheated. An overheated rotor can't be trusted to stop the car evenly.
If the rotors are above the minimum thickness, the surface is smooth and the brakes don't shake, new pads alone are often fine. That's most likely when you come in at the first squeal, before the pads wear down to the metal.
New pads start around 12 mm thick, and the conversation about replacing them starts near 3 mm. Have your brakes checked every 6 months or 6,000 miles and you'll usually catch them in time.
Worn rotors with pads still on them usually get you to a shop, but don't put it off. Grinding and shaking get worse, and a thin rotor runs hot.
If the pedal feels soft or sinks, the car pulls hard to one side, or the red brake warning light comes on, don't drive it. Have it towed.
Pads with rotors costs more than pads alone, so it's worth knowing which one you need. At Budget Brakes the free six-point inspection checks the pads, rotors, brake fluid and hardware, and we show you the pad measurements. Lifetime warranty brakes start from $100, and you get a written price before any work starts. What a brake job costs.
Measured, not guessed. New pads start around 12 mm. We start the conversation near 3 mm, and you see the number.
Sixteen shops. One way of doing things.
Quality parts at low prices, an honest look at what your car needs, and a guarantee that travels with you to any Budget Brakes.